Category: Decision Reviews

Ghiath Nasser > Blog > Decision Reviews

The Israeli Supreme Court invalidates the law abolishing the criterion of reasonability – Lawyer Ghiath Nasser

Today, January 1, 2023, the Israeli Supreme Court issued an important decision repealing the Basic Judicial Law (Amendment No. 3), which abolishes the standard of reasonableness that the court can use during judicial oversight of government decisions. This law was enacted by the government as part of a package of laws that the government wishes […]

Read More

High Court rejects Gaza students’ petition to study in West Bank

High Court rejects Gaza students’ petition to study in West Bank Israel has barred Gaza residents from studying in the West Bank since 2000, and in the 12 years since has only allowed three Gaza residents to study at universities in the West Bank. By Amira Hass, Haaretz Newspaper, at 27.09.12 . The High Court of […]

Read More

Supreme Court denied petition to open investigation against the army

 Supreme Court denied petition to open investigation against the army In a new Judgment issued on 8.12.2011 the Israeli Supreme Court denied petition against the General Attorney and against the State of Israel to force them open criminal investigation against army personal that were involved on military operation which was carried out by the army […]

Read More

The Supreme Court judgment concerning the Wall in Kalandya village

The Israeli Supreme Court Judgment  concerning the Wall in Kalandya village in Jerusalem The Israeli Supreme Court accepted the petition of the state of Israel concerning the wall plan in kalandya village in Jerusalem and decided that although the state can build the wall in the planned route, the state should build a Checkpoint in the […]

Read More

Supreme Court Denied two Childs plea to have resident ID

Supreme Court Denied two Childs plea to have resident ID The Israeli Supreme Court Denied the plea of two Palestinian Childs from Jerusalem (Tzur Baher neighborhood) to have resident Id, although the their hole family and brothers hold such a Jerusalem ID. The Judges of the Supreme Court were divided in their opinions. President of […]

Read More

Palestinian prisoner petition for release from administrative detention was denied without reasoning

Palestinian prisoner petition for release from administrative detention was denied without reasoning The Israeli Supreme Court denied yesterday 21.11.2011 the petition of the palestinian prisoner Majed Abo Sbeh for release from administrative detention. The judgment dining the petition include no more than two sentences and without any appropriate reasoning. the judgment was issued after the court considered […]

Read More

The Supreme Court approved a plan for expanding settelment

The Supreme Court approved a plan for expanding settelment The Israeli Supreme Court denied a petition against the legalization and expanding of Talmon settlement in the West Bank and approved a plan for building 300 units in the settlement. at the beginning 56 buildings were built illegally by settlers and now according to the new […]

Read More

Israeli HCJ denied Palestinian prisoner petition for disclosure of secret evidence in his file

Israeli HCJ denied Palestinian prisoner petition for disclosure of secret evidence in his file The Israeli High Court of Justice (HCJ) denied the petition of the Palestinian prisoner Ayman Saied Muhamad Hmedeh asking for disclosure of secret evidence in his file before the Military Court. the defense attorney asked the military court to call for testimony the “people” […]

Read More

The Israeli HCJ Denied Palestinian prisoner petition for release from detention

 The Israeli Supreme Court Denied the petition of Palestinian prisoner to be released from administrative detention  The Israeli Supreme Court sitting as High Court of Justice (HCJ) denied on 8/11/2011 the petition of the Palestinian prisoner Hazem Al-Taweel for his release from military Administrative detention. Administrative detention, is a detention by order of the Israeli […]

Read More

Israeli Supreme Court judgment concerning the prisoners of the Gaza flotilla participants

Israeli Supreme Court judgment concerning the prisoners of the Gaza flotilla participants Hereinafter the Israeli Supreme Court Judgment concerning the petitions asking for Habeas corpus order to release the participants in the flotilla to Gaza from the Israeli prison, which was issued on June, 2, 2010. The Supreme Court sitting as the High Court of Justice […]

Read More

The judgment of the supreme court concerning road 443

The judgment of the Supreme Court concerning road 443 The Israeli Supreme Court judgment concerning the petition challenging the prohibition of Palestinians from using road 443 in the West Bank, road which is used by Israelis. The petition was granted, taking into consideration security arrangements. after the judgment, and as a result of these strict […]

Read More

The Israeli Supreme Court Judgment concerning detention orders

The Israeli Supreme Court Judgment concerning detention orders on the West Bank The Judgment of the Israeli Supreme Court sitting as High Court of Justice concerning the enactment of new military orders on the Palestinian Occupied Territories during a military operation by the IDF on the west bank Called “Defense wall operation”. according to these […]

Read More

The supreme Court approved acquisition order by IDF

The supreme Court approved acquisition order by IDF The Israeli Supreme Court denied the petition of Bethlehem Municipality against acquisition order issued by the Israeli Army in order to pave a road for Rachel Tomb in the entrance of Bethlehem city. Hereinafter the judgment of the Court:    HCJ 1890/03 Bethlehem Municipality and 22 others v 1.     […]

Read More

Mohammed Alamarin v. IDF Commander in Gaza Strip

Mohammed Alamarin v. IDF Commander in Gaza Strip House Demolition orders in the palestinians territories Hereinafter the Judjment of the Supreme Court concerning Alamarin Case which was issued on june 1992. HCJ 2722/92 Mohammed Alamarin v. IDF Commander in Gaza Strip The Supreme Court sitting as the High Court of Justice [14 June 1992] Before […]

Read More

Louie Salama v. Israel Defence Force (IDF) Commander in Judea and Samaria

Judgmment of the Supreme Court concerning Administrative detention Hereinafter Judgment of the Israeli Supreme Court in which the Court denied palestinians petitions against detention orders. HCJ 5784/03 HCJ 6024/03 HCJ 6025/03 1.Louie Salama 2.Abd al Razek Farg 3.Hail Abu Hassen v. 1.Israel Defence Force (IDF) Commander in Judea and Samaria 2.Judge of the Military Appeals Court […]

Read More

Supreme Court Approved Requisition order in Hebron

Israeli Supreme Court Approved Requisition order of private land in Hebron  The Israeli Supreme Court Denied petition against Requisition order of palestinians private land and against demolition order in Hebronin order to pave a road for Machpela Cave. Hereinafter the judgment: HCJ 10356/02 1.         Yoav Hass 2.         MK Musi Raz 3.         ‘Yesh Gevul’ Movement v. 1.         IDF […]

Read More

The Israel HCJ denied Physicians for Human Rights petition concerning The humanitarian situation in Gaza…

The Israeli Supreme Court denied petition filed by Physicians for Human Rights, concerning Gaza Strip during the war by Ghiath Nasser, adv. The Israeli Supreme court denied a petition which was filed by  Physicians for Human Rights organization chalenging the evacuation of wounded to hospitals in the Gaza Strip, and claims that ambulances and medical personnel […]

Read More

Decision Reviews of Israeli Supreme Court concerning Occupied Territories

Reviews of Decisions of the Israeli Supreme Court concerning casesof the Palestinians living in the Occupied Territories  Ghiath Nasser, Adv.  At the end of the 1967 War, Israel established a military government designated to control the Palestinian Occupied Territories of the West Bank and Gaza Strip. This government issued the Order concerning local courts (status of […]

Read More